Rob Oller: Plain and simple, Buckeyes got beat by the much better team

Rob Oller
Buckeye Xtra

Sometimes you get beat because the other guy is just that much better.

Or in the case of Alabama, the other guys, plural — although for 30 minutes on Monday night in suburban Miami it appeared that Crimson Tide receiver DeVonta Smith might outscore Ohio State all by his lonesome.

Ohio State-Alabama:Cornerback Shaun Wade has not ruled out return to Ohio State football in 2021

Regardless, the better team won. The much better team. Play 10 times and the Buckeyes maybe win two. Three, if things fall exactly right. The Tide showed it is a worthy champion by clocking OSU 52-24.

There is no shame in Ohio State losing to Nick Saban — now with seven national titles overall — and an Alabama offense that ranks among the best ever. The Crimson Tide rolled up 389 yards the first half alone (and 621 overall), more than OSU totaled for the game (341).

Allowing 52 points is unacceptable, and for many scarlet and gray devotees depressingly unwatchable, but dropping chin to chest meant not seeing a performance as pretty in its perfection as it was painful for those on the wrong end of it.

Regardless of allegiance, this was electric entertainment for those who relish high-octane offense — 60 minutes of Fast & Furious and silencing the old-school saying that defense wins championships. That notion no longer holds, not when two teams with elite playmakers — and, in the case of Alabama, exceptional play-calling — show up to see which can hang half a hundred on the other.

Alabama is a top-of-the-line college program of these times: Play offense until the other team cracks. On Monday, Ohio State cracked under the relentless pressure put on by running back Najee Harris (22) and others.

Let’s be clear, Alabama got the better of the Buckeyes not because Ohio State is overrated but because the Tide might be underrated, even at 13-0. You will watch years of college football before finding another quarterback/running back/receiver trio that executes as well as Mac Jones, Najee Harris and Smith.

Smith was spectacular, catching 12 passes for 215 yards and three touchdowns. By halftime. And in case anyone thinks the Heisman Trophy winner is a one-man show, that without him 'Bama is merely human, the Crimson Tide scored 17 points after Smith injured his right hand 30 seconds into the third quarter and did not return.

Shudder to think what the score might have been had he played the entire game. Poor Tuf Borland. If there were a meme for what happened in Hard Rock Stadium it would be the Ohio State linebacker struggling to cover Smith on a 42-yard touchdown pass late in the first half. It was like watching an unnatural nature show in which the lumbering elk chases the wolves.

Bottom Line analysis:Alabama takes Ohio State to the woodshed

Certainly, OSU’s pass defense needs work — it ranked 122nd among 127 Football Bowl Subdivision teams in yards allowed per game — mostly because it lacks both the NFL first-round pass rusher and lockdown cornerback it has been spoiled with the past six seasons.

But against most teams, including a not-too-shabby Clemson in the Sugar Bowl on Jan. 1, the overall defense was solid. Alabama’s offense is simply that good.   

“That’s one of the better offenses in college football in a long time,” Ohio State coach Ryan Day said, adding that trying to match Alabama point for point took a toll. “There’s a feeling that if you don’t score, the pressure mounts.”

Oh, to have been a fly on the locker room wall at halftime as Ohio State defensive co-coordinator Kerry Coombs plotted a strategy to slow the Crimson Tide. The plan mostly failed, but to be fair it had to be like stopping a tsunami with one sandbag.

How is Buckeye Nation taking it? Already there is some harrumphing as fans see in this loss shades of the debacle in the desert after the 2006 season, when after posting a 12-0 record through the regular season the Buckeyes fell apart in losing to Florida 41-14 in the BCS championship game in Arizona.

Bah. Are there interesting similarities? Yes. Just as the Buckeyes lost Ted Ginn Jr. on the opening kickoff return for a touchdown against Florida, OSU lost tailback Trey Sermon on its first play from scrimmage against Alabama. Justin Fields did not look 100% following his hip injury against Clemson. Likewise, Troy Smith struggled following a Heisman hangover that saw his weight balloon as he made his way through the awards circuit. And the coaching strategy in both games seemed scattered.

Ohio State football:Quarterback Justin Fields copes with injuries in final loss to Alabama

But where the 2006 Buckeyes were favored by a touchdown against the Gators, the 2020 Buckeyes were 8½-point underdogs who would have needed to play like they did against Clemson to hang with Alabama. Hang they did — it was 21-17 with 5:21 left in the half — before the Tide hung 14 points on them to make it 35-17.

Some will make the excuse that Ohio State lost due to attrition, including Sermon and starting defensive linemen Tommy Togiai and Tyreke Smith, both unavailable for reasons thought to be related to COVID-19 testing.

Again, bah. Alabama was just better. And it has little to do with Ohio State playing only eight games to the Tide's 13. Tip your cap and be thankful the Buckeyes got this far in a season when a virus was the second-toughest opponent.


Get more Ohio State football news by listening to our podcasts