Mailbox: Ohio State should have asterisk removed; and did Quinn Ewers pay his taxes?

Brian White
The Columbus Dispatch

Have more comments, questions? Reach out to me at

Ohio State football players (from left) DeVier Posey, Mike Adams, Boom Herron, Terrelle Pryor were suspended by the NCAA  for selling rings, jerseys and awards and receiving improper benefits from a tattoo parlor.

On Ohio State football

To Brian: Even after severe sanctions for cheating, SMU football still kept on paying their players and was finally given the death penalty, but not one of those wins by that team using all those paid players for so long was ever vacated. In 2010, Ohio State had a few players sell their own items and ended up with all 12 wins that season being vacated, including the Sugar Bowl which the NCAA told OSU to use those players in after knowing of the violations. It's time those 12 wins be restored and that asterisk removed.  

Dennis Singleton, Dayton

To Dennis: I can't answer for the SMU scandal, but what Ohio State's players did was against NCAA rules in 2010 and is against NCAA rules now. So I don't anticipate the NCAA apologizing.

More:Mailbox: Is Quinn Ewers the new Curt Flood? Did refs let Michigan get away with holding?

Ohio State Buckeyes linebacker Steele Chambers (22) pursues Indiana Hoosiers running back Stephen Carr (5) during the NCAA football game at Memorial Stadium in Bloomington, Ind. on Sunday, Oct. 24, 2021. Ohio State won 54-7.

To the editor: Good article on not just Steele Chambers, but also about the new coach and the whole defensive scheme. Good nuts and bolts stuff.

Bill, Hilliard

To Bill: All the credit there goes to our Bill Rabinowitz, who continues to ask good questions and provide good depth to what is going on with the OSU football team.

Freshman quarterback Quinn Ewers (3) did not see any reps during Wednesday’s 11-on-11 period.

On NIL and taxes

Dear Mr. White: April 18 was tax day not only for millions of normal wage-earning Americans but also for a new breed of filers: Name, image and likeness college athletes. (My initial thought: Did Quinn Ewers remember to file an Ohio state tax return for monies received in 2021 while holding down the job of quarterback No. 3 for the Buckeyes? My guess is: yes.)

More:Former Ohio State football quarterback Quinn Ewers announces he is heading to Texas

While I’ve never received a Form 1099 for $1 million in recognition of my work as a pitchman for Big Al’s Chevrolet in East Lansing/Tuscaloosa/ Norman/College Station, I’ll bet it would gets one’s full attention. (Note to self: please tell me I left $300,000 or so of dry powder to satisfy my tax obligations, you know, before I bought the Hummer and parked the rest in Bitcoin.)  Assuming everyone acted prudently, April 18 produced two windfalls: one for government revenue agencies at all levels, and a second for the battalion of CPAs that headline-averse university athletic departments had to hire to battle the complexities of the tax code.  After all, one headline they want to avoid: “On eve of big game vs. Tech, State quarterback indicted for income tax evasion.”

Jon Armstrong, Columbus

More from The Mailbox

Reader longs for the days Ohio State Buckeyes football played a real spring game

Baker Mayfield getting a bad rap in this Deshaun Watson mess

In defense of Chris Holtmann, and the Browns need Kevin Costner again

Readers want to know why Ohio State men's basketball isn't an elite program

Readers disagree on direction of Ohio State basketball under Chris Holtmann

Illinois fans don't like fingers pointed at their angry coach

Why are Illinois, Michigan OK with the behavior of their basketball coaches?

Why does Notre Dame get a CFP vote? And is Rob Oller great or 'sad and cynical'?

On Joe Burrow, a man of many academic degrees

Reader says Ohio State Buckeyes 'dropped the ball' by not starting Joe Burrow

Get more Ohio State news by listening to our podcasts